This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

In partnership with

Hi, {{first_name|friend}}. 👋

Last week, we discussed how to actually restart a newsletter that’s been quiet for a long time.

This week, I’m sharing what I found after comparing two years of sends, since momentum has stalled. 🤷‍♂️

Over the last 12 months, my dashboard showed active subscribers up 5.9%, open rate up 1.5%, and earnings up 2.4%.

Click rate, however, was down 14.9%.

🤔 Having written plenty about unreliable email metrics, I thought I should take a closer look at my own to figure out what’s going on.

Let’s go! 👇

The daily newsletter for finding AI tools worth trying

New AI tools launch every day. A few will change how you work. The rest will be forgotten by next month.

TLDR AI is the free newsletter that tells you which is which. Every morning, Anthropic and ex-Google engineers pick the new tools, updates, and open source releases worth trying, with a quick note on what each one does and who it's for.

You find the good ones early, without testing all of them.

One email, 5 minutes a day, read by 1.1M+ people. Get tomorrow's picks.

What Has Actually Been Bothering Me?

First, a definition so you can understand what I’ve been looking at.

It’s also worth noting that I regularly look back at audience data over the following previous periods:

  • 4 weeks.

  • 3 months.

  • 6 months,

  • 12 months.

💡 The rate calculated in this analysis is unique clicks divided by recorded unique opens: the click-to-open rate (yes, I know open rates are ’t reliable).

  • Across regular issues, average raw unique clicks barely changed between the two annual periods:

    • Roughly 44 per issue previously, compared with 46 in the latest year.

  • Recorded unique opens increased from about 301 to 372.

The percentage fell, even though roughly the same number of people clicked each issue.

That helps explain the annual comparison. It doesn’t tell me whether the additional openers are new subscribers, or whether the people clicking have changed.

And it doesn’t explain everything else I found. 👇

The Annual Average Hid a Bigger Change

💡 Before we go any further, what do I mean by “verified” clicks?

Security software can automatically click links to check whether they’re safe. Those clicks can appear in your stats even though the subscriber hasn’t clicked anything.

Beehiiv’s verified clicks filter out likely automated activity using signals such as IP addresses, browser information, and click patterns.

When I say “verified unique clicks”, each subscriber with a click that passes those checks counts once per issue, regardless of how many links they click.

🧠 It’s a filtered measure of likely human activity, rather than a guarantee that every click came from a person.

When I split the latest year into two periods, the picture changed.

  • November to April: about 43 verified unique clicks per regular issue.

  • May to November: about 29.

Recorded unique opens barely changed: about 376 versus 370.

🚨 That’s roughly a third fewer verified clickers per issue.

The two newest issues had less time to collect clicks when I pulled the data. Even excluding them, the decline remains.

September and October averaged about 25 verified unique clickers. Summer 2025 averaged 42, with a similar number of recipients (and engagement generally goes down during the summer, so it’s concerning).

The audiences and content differed, so this isn’t a controlled comparison. But with similar recipient numbers and fewer verified clicks, list growth alone doesn’t explain the decline.

My Audience Changed Along the Way

In August 2025, I cleaned my list, but I made a big mistake when doing so:

  • Issue #204 went to 657 recipients;

  • Issue #205 went to 538 recipients.

Click-to-open rates were higher after the clean-up, which affects how I interpret the later decline. And the audience changed again in May.

🤦‍♂️ If you read Issue #237, you might remember me changing my re-engagement automation trigger on a Friday. That went well…not! 🫠

The new rules applied to existing subscribers straight away, which I wasn’t expecting.

💡 The decline had already started by then, so I can’t blame the automation for all of it. But it’s another change to the list that I need to consider when comparing the numbers.

Were the Topics the Problem?

Possibly in some cases.

But the results don’t give me a simple answer…

💡 Those issues included resources readers could check, tools they could try, and changes they wanted to understand.

But I can’t simply conclude that I should write more practical content.

Issue #241, about the Email Markup Consortium’s accessibility report, had 52 verified unique clicks. Issue #256, where I questioned the claims about AI adoption and accessibility, had 11.

Both covered accessibility, but they offered readers different things. One explored problems found in actual emails; the other examined what we could reasonably take from a research headline.

🤔 Did readers get what they needed from the email itself? Or did the links give them less reason to click?

I can’t answer that from the click counts alone. But I wouldn’t look at Issue #256 and conclude that you lovely readers aren’t interested in accessibility.

What Can I Actually Conclude?

💡 Looking at the numbers, two things stand out:

  • Across the two annual periods, recorded opens increased, but average raw unique clickers per issue barely changed.

  • Within the latest year, average verified unique clickers per issue fell substantially.

So, list growth doesn’t explain the whole decline. Fewer subscribers are registering verified clicks per issue.

But that doesn’t tell me whether fewer people are reading, or whether the newsletter has become less useful.

As I explored in Issue #237, you might get what you need from the email without following a link.

🤔 Equally, you might find the links less interesting or useful than before. I can’t tell which from the click counts alone.

That’s something I need to ask you.

What Would I Change?

In Issue #253, Travis Hazlewood explored click behaviour. One point I picked out was the importance of the primary CTA: what’s the main thing you’re asking someone to do?

🤔 For me, that means looking at the links themselves:

  • Have I explained why they’re worth your time?

  • Is there something useful waiting on the other side, or have I already covered everything in the email?

Those are things I can review and test across several issues.

Something I’m Already Trying

🎉 You might have noticed the new interactive quiz section, built using Atrivial (ironically, not used in this issue).

I introduced it to give you another way to take part, test what you’ve learned, and hopefully have a bit of fun.

💡 But adding another reason to click also changes what I’m measuring. If clicks increase, I’d want to know whether that’s people opening the quiz, following the other links, or both.

And opening a quiz isn’t the same as completing it (most of you don’t), or finding it useful (again, maybe you don’t).

Your feedback matters here too.

What Would Count as an Improvement?

I’d compare issues after the same amount of time and track:

  • Verified unique clicks per issue.

  • Verified unique clicks as a percentage of delivered emails.

That lets me monitor clicking without relying on recorded opens as the denominator.

I’d also look at where those clicks go and what you tell me in your replies.

🚨 What I wouldn’t do is remove subscribers simply to improve the percentage. After my experience with re-engagement triggers, I’d want a better reason than making the dashboard look healthier.

Before You Go

I’d have liked to finish this with a neat explanation of why my click rate fell.

🤷‍♂️ I haven’t got one. And after spending this much time looking at the numbers, that’s more than a little frustrating.

But I have a clearer picture of what changed, and which conclusions I’d be making without enough evidence.

💡 If you’re looking at a decline in your own newsletter, I hope that’s useful. Before changing your content, questioning where your subscribers came from, or removing people from your list, check what the figures actually tell you.

I’ve already shared what happened when I put too much weight on whether someone clicked. I don’t want to repeat that mistake.

I want this newsletter to be worth your time. Useful links are part of that, but so are the explanations, opinions and occasional ramblings you get without leaving your inbox. 😂

So, before I make changes based on what “I think” you want, I’d like to ask you.

🤔 What do you find most useful about All About Email, and what would you change?

Hit reply, {{first_name|friend}}. I’d love to hear.

That’s it for this week. 👋

Simon

All About Email - Playlist 🎧

Every week, as I write this newsletter, I’ll share the track of the moment to create an unbelievably eclectic playlist just for your inbox.

Sponsorship Opportunities

🚨 If you’re interested in sponsoring the “All About Email” newsletter, you can find all the details in this Google Doc.

Email Marketing News & Tips

This week's excellent and insightful email news & tips:

  • A Type of Accessibility - A handbook for creating accessible HTML emails. NEW! (Beyond the Envelope)

  • 😬 Oh Dear! - List Verification Suspicion Confirmed. (Word to the Wise)

  • Email Is Easy - Can you just send a quick email? (Lauren Meyer)

  • Trending - 7 Holiday Marketing Trends to Guide Your Peak Season Strategy in 2026. (Mailchimp)

  • 🧠 Shaping Up - The 5 Growth Levers Behind Every Fast-Growing Newsletter. (Growth In Reverse)

  • What Is Email Filtering? - How Email Filters Decide If You Reach the Inbox (Kickbox)

  • 🤠 Round-Up - A rough week, but we survived. (Spam Resource)

  • Email Marketing Optimization - 15 ways to improve campaigns. (Valimail)

If you have any questions about this email or email marketing, please reply, and I will get back to you as soon as possible.

I hope you have a great week! 👋

Simon Harper's handwritten signaturee